So Many Types of Book Editing! Where to Start?
Updated: Oct 8
If you've ever asked three editors what they do and gotten three different answers, you're not alone. The terms get used loosely, and it can be hard to know which service your manuscript actually needs. Here's how I think about the different types of editing, in the order they usually happen.
Developmental editing looks at the story as a whole: plot, structure, characters, and pacing.
Line editing looks at the writing itself: flow, word choice, clarity, and voice.
Copyediting makes the manuscript correct and consistent: grammar, punctuation, word usage, and details that have to match from chapter to chapter.
Proofreading is the final check for any typos and mistakes that are left.
Developmental editing: the big picture
Developmental editing (sometimes called content editing) looks at the foundation of your story. I read for plot holes, structure and pacing, character goals and growth, and emotional depth and theme. The feedback comes as an editorial letter with overall notes, plus comments in the manuscript to guide your revisions.
This is the right choice when you have a finished draft and want to know whether the story is working. It's also the stage where big changes are still easy to make. Moving a chapter or rewriting a subplot is far simpler before anyone polishes the sentences. And if you changed things around during the drafting stage, developmental editors will catch pesky gremlins you overlooked.
Additionally, if you do line editing or polish the sentences before doing a developmental edit, you risk wasting time and money wordsmithing scenes, chapters, or characters that might end up getting cut or heavily rewritten.
Line editing: the sentences
Line editing works on the prose itself: flow, word choice, pacing at the sentence level, clarity, and voice. I'm not changing your story. I'm helping each sentence do its job while keeping it sounding like you.
Choose line editing when the story's plot is solid and you're happy with the structure, but the writing is clunky, repetitive, or uneven.
Copyediting: the details
Copyediting is where the manuscript gets cleaned up and made consistent. A copyeditor checks grammar, spelling, punctuation, and word usage, and makes sure the details match from chapter to chapter, like a character's eye color or the timeline. Many copyeditors also keep a style sheet, a running list of those choices, so everything stays consistent.
But copy and line sound alike!
Line editing is about art and voice: it’s creative. It looks at rhythm, flow, clichés, clunky phrasing, and whether a sentence captures the emotion you want.
Copyediting is about rules and consistency: it’s technical. It looks at grammar rules, spelling, punctuation consistency, formatting styles (like "OK" vs. "okay"), and tracking whether a timeline or fact matches up.
Copyediting comes after line editing. If your sentences are still going to change, you may end up paying to fix punctuation twice. Choose copyediting when the story and the prose are where you want them and you want the manuscript clean before the final check.
Do you have to buy copyediting as a completely separate, standalone service? Not always. Many freelance editors bundle line editing and copyediting into a single combined pass to save you time and money (like myself!).
Proofreading: the final check
Proofreading is the last pass before your book goes out into the world. It catches typos, repeated or missing words, and formatting problems that are still left. A proofreader isn't there to improve your writing, only to clean it up.
Proofreading only makes sense on a manuscript that is finished. If you're still rewriting scenes, anything a proofreader fixes may end up being thrown away.
Where beta reading fits
A beta read is a lighter option than developmental editing. It gives you a reader's-eye view of your story: where it pulled them in, where they got lost, and what they'd change. It's a good first step if you want honest reactions before committing to a deeper edit, and it costs less.
Why the order matters
Each stage assumes that the one before is done. Working from big to small means every stage builds on solid ground.
So which one do you need?
Not sure the story works yet? Start with developmental editing, or a beta read.
Story works but the prose needs polish? Line editing.
Prose is polished, but the details need checking? Copyediting.
Everything is done and you're about to publish? Proofreading.
Many authors use them one after another, and bundling the services can save money. But you don't need every edit every time. A good editor will tell you honestly which one your manuscript is ready for. And the more you work with an editor, the more you'll catch your own weak spots, which makes your life easier and your editor love you.
Once you know which one you need, here's what it costs: How Much Does a Book Editor Cost?
Common mix-ups
Expecting proofreading to fix the story. A proofreader checks mechanics, not plot or pacing.
Expecting line editing to fix structure. It improves the sentences, but it won't reorganize your plot.
Skipping a step to save money. Sometimes that's fine, but be sure your manuscript is truly ready for the stage you're buying. (Take it from someone who learned the hard way!)
Assuming editors define the terms the same way. Always ask what's included before you hire.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need all of them?
Not necessarily. A manuscript with a strong structure may only need line editing, copyediting, and proofreading. Others may need a developmental edit and a lot of revision before polishing the prose.
Can one editor do more than one?
Often, yes. And some authors prefer it because the editor already knows the book. Just keep in mind that each stage has a different focus.
How do I know my manuscript is ready for proofreading?
When you've finished revising and don't plan to change the story, scenes, or wording in any significant way. If you're still tinkering, it's too early.
Not sure where your manuscript falls? I offer a free 1,000-word sample edit so you can see how I work before committing to anything. You can find the details at scarborougheditorial.com.




Comments